• Home
  • /
  • Fitness
  • /
  • Dr. Darrell Menard: Will swimming keep me as fit as my running program?

Dr. Darrell Menard: Will swimming keep me as fit as my running program?

Ask the expert: Will swimming keep me as fit as my running program?

Dr. Darrell-Menard

Q:  I seriously injured my right knee playing high school football and have functioned very well until recently when my knee started getting sore and swelling after long runs and rucksack marches.  X-rays show I have arthritis in this knee and I was advised to run less and to do more low impact fitness activities.  I have started swimming but I wonder if this will keep me as fit as my running program?  Captain Coureur

A: Dear Captain Coureur: Glad to hear you are staying active.  Swimming and running are both excellent forms of cardiovascular exercise that offer many health benefits but they aren’t suited to everyone.  Here is a brief comparison of some the advantages each of these activities have to offer:

  1. Running may be a better choice if you are trying to lose weight. The Mayo Clinic estimates that if you run and swim at the same intensity, you will burn approximately 40% more calories running than you will swimming;
  2. The resistance provided by water makes swimming a better full body workout;
  3. Running is a more convenient activity as it can be done nearly anywhere, any time and with minimal equipment;
  4. Swimming is a more flexible activity. You can do a number of different strokes such as breast stroke, front crawl and butterfly.  You can also change things up by using equipment such as fins, paddles, pull buoys and kick boards. This variety allows swimmers to work different muscle groups and train at different intensities all in the same workout.  Runners can vary the intensity of their training but not their technique;
  5. Running is one of the simplest forms of exercise that most people instinctively learn to do in early childhood. Swimming is a skill people must be taught and practice to be able to do well;
  6. Swimming is a “No” impact form of exercise that is far more gentle on your joints than running. Given this lack of impact, runners often use swimming to stay fit while they recover from their injuries;
  7. Running is a high impact activity that can help increase the strength of your bones;
  8. Swimmers never have to worry about angry dogs, distracted drivers or bad weather;
  9. And running and swimming can both be a lot of fun.

The bottom line: Swimming and running are both excellent ways to stay fit and you don’t have to choose between doing one or the other.  Many people alternate running and swimming workouts and in that way get to enjoy the benefits of both – something we call cross training.  Give this excellent fitness strategy a try – I think your knees will love you for it. Train smart and remember exercise is medicine!

Dr. Darrell Menard OMM MD, Dip Sport Med

Dr. Menard is the Surgeon General’s specialist advisor in sports medicine and has worked extensively with athletes from multiple sports.  As part of the Strengthening the Forces team he works on injury prevention and promoting active living.

One Comment

  • Mitchell MacLeod 13139

    August 13, 2019 at 5:17 pm

    Interesting article. I am in the process of losing a significant amount of weight(41 lbs so far) and am wondering the way ahead to help keep it off once I reach my goal, not being sure if my 60 year old back and legs would take kindly to daily running. I think I was fairly active before, just overweight, and have stepped up being on the ice as a goaltender to five days a week in recent weeks, but I am interested in alternating that some days moving forward. BTW then Major Menard treated my injuries in Croatia in 1999 when I broke my arm and compressed my lower back jumping out of a perfectly good airplane at the CISM World Meet. I enjoy reading his sound advice.